E2S manufacture an extensive range of alarm horns or sounders suitable for many applications. The efficiency of any audible signaling device depends on: the size and / or distance of the area to be covered, the background noise and the pattern & frequency of tone
The effective distance of a sounder is when the calculated dB(A) reaches at least 5dB(A) above the known ambient background noise. For example the effective distance of a 100dB(A)@1 metre sounder in an ambient noise of 65dB(A) is the distance at which the sounder output level reduces to 70 dB(A) i.e. 100 dB – 30 dB = 70dB. From the above table (and using the inverse square rule) a reduction of 30 dB means the sounder has an effective 70dB distance of 32 metres.
A 120dB(A) @ 1 metre sounder has a 70dB distance of approximately 300 metres i.e.ten times the effective distance and, more importantly 100 times the coverage area.
Remember
- In the open, sound will spread in all directions. In an enclosed space some
of the sound will be reflected and increase the sound level.
- All-mounted sounder is positioned near a ceiling, more sound will be reflected.
The same is true for a ceiling mounted sounder near a wall.
- A sounder mounted on a wall is more effective than one mounted on a pillar.
- Sounders should be sited to avoid immediate obstacles, ideally at a height of
approx. 2 to 2.5 metres.
- Synchronized sounders will give a more effective overall effect.
- Personnel may be wearing ear protection.
Sound Output Attenuation: Frequency and Tone Pattern
Sound output is also affected by the frequency of the sound. Lower frequencies tend to travel further, penetrate structures better and are less likely to be attenuated by obstructions. A further adjustment to the range of a sounder may be made according
to the frequency of the tone as shown below.
Frequency of sounder
|
Adjustment
|
| Up to 500Hz |
0dBA |
| 500Hz to 1000Hz |
-3dBA |
| 1000Hz to 2000Hz |
-5dBA
|
However
Perception of a tone is not entirely dependent on frequency and sound level. An output
with differing frequencies and/or temporal pattern will have a more distinct sound. This
can be useful in areas of background noise where hearing protection may be worn. Usually two-tone frequencies, intermittent, ramp-up frequencies or ramp-down frequencies are the most effective.
How many Sounders do I need?
When the area to be covered is large and / or noisy, designers often add more sounders. This could lead to an inadequate coverage, if the alarm sounders were positioned incorrectly or require the addition of more sounders to achieve the bare minimum alarm level.
Example:
Question: A 30m by 20m room, with very little background noise (approx. 65dB(A)), is satisfactorily covered by a 100dB(A) sounder with a 70dB(A) range of approximately 30m. How many sounders would you need if heavy machinery meant the background noise was 85dB(A)?
Answer: One! If the background noise increases by 20dB, install a sounder 20dB louder i.e. a sounder rated at 120dB(A). This simple principle is often forgotten in the need to cover large and noisy areas.
The effective distance of a 100 dB(A) sounder in a very noisy environment is 1.8m, the distance for a 120 dB(A) sounder is approx 18m (10 times the distance).
Note: Alarm sounders that are too loud may be dangerous and cause panic, discomfort
and make communication very difficult. As guidance, the overall alarm level should be
a maximum of 10 to 15 dB(A) over the ambient background noise.
To achieve 90bB(A) in an area 50 x 30m
Either fit eighty A100 (100dB(A) at 1m) units or fit just two A121 (121dB(A) at 1m) units
More Design Considerations
Sounders aren’t generally effective at an output lower than 65 to 70dB(A) or less than 5dB above the ambient, background noise. Additional sounders or louder sounders may be necessary after calculating the maximum distance and coverage required. Any adjustment according to the output frequency should also be factored in.
Internal fire doors attenuate sound by at least 30dB, and normal doors at least 20dB. It’s advisable that any sounder isn’t required to be heard through more than one partition.
In the above example;
The attenuation caused by distance d1, the door & partition and distance d2 must be calculated (with an adjustment for tone frequency). The final dB(A) level should be not less than 65 to 70dB(A) or not less than 5dB above the background level in area 2.
Care should be taken not to use a sounder with too higher output in area 1 simply to achieve an acceptable level in area 2 as this may make levels in area 1, particularly close to the sounder, unacceptably loud.
Sound Output of Multiple Sounders
Two sounders together with an equal output increases the total output by 3dB. So two 100 dB(A) sounders together will provide 103dB(A) total.
Four 100dB(A) sounders will deliver 106dB(A) in total. It’s important to establish the most suitable sounder at the design stage as simply adding more of the same sounders may only increase an overall alarm level by a few dB.
Disaster warning / Wide area signaling
Large sounders with high outputs of typically 140dB(A) and above have additional considerations such as:
- Attenuation caused by ground effects, barriers such as buildings
- Vertical temperature gradients
- Atmospheric refraction
- Sound absorption in the atmosphere
- People’s perception
- Building construction
It is important to realise predicting coverage can only be an estimate. A combination of these factors attenuating sound in the atmosphere, is both complicated and unpredictable.
Strong winds will influence the effectiveness of the sound coverage. It will tend to make the sound travel further in the direction it is blowing, i.e. in the same direction as gas will be blown in the event of a leak.
In general, disaster warning sounders should be mounted horizontally 10 to 15 metres above the ground, preferably at the highest point on the site to be covered (although not so high that the sound travels over the top of the area). As a general guide, take the height of any obstruction within 50m and keep the sounder at least 2m higher than this for best sound coverage - ideally the source to target should be aimed or “line of sight”.